Warm café interior with coffee and pastries on a wooden table
McAlisterville's Favorite Café & Bar

From Morning Foam to Evening Pour —
Every Sip Has a Story

Handcrafted lattes, fresh-baked pastries, and small-batch cocktails — all under one roof in the heart of central Pennsylvania.

Local & Loved
Made with Care
Good Vibes Only

Specialty Coffee

Single-origin beans, expertly roasted and pulled into espresso shots that taste like a moment of peace in a cup.

Fresh-Baked Daily

Pastries, cookies, and breads baked each morning — because nothing beats the smell of something made from scratch.

Cocktails & Brews

When the sun sets, the bar wakes up. Handcrafted cocktails, local drafts, and a warm atmosphere to unwind in.

Right in Town

Right on PA-35 in McAlisterville — easy to find, easy to park, and impossible to forget after one visit.

Cozy interior of The Creme Stop café with warm lighting
Latte art in a ceramic cup on a marble surface

More Than a Café —
It's a Stop

The Creme Stop was born from a simple idea: what if a place could feel like both a morning ritual and an evening escape? We opened our doors on PA-35 in McAlisterville with that question in mind.

By day, we pour coffee with the same care you'd find at a specialty roaster — single-origin beans, precise pulls, milk steamed to silk. By night, the same space transforms into a neighborhood bar with craft cocktails, local drafts, and the kind of easy conversation that happens when the lights are low and the music is just right.

We're not a chain. We're not trying to be somewhere else. We're just a small team that believes great drinks and good company make a town feel like home.

Single-Origin Coffee Beans
Baked Fresh Every Morning
Local Breweries & Producers

Come For the Drink,
Stay for the Feeling

Warm wood, soft lighting, and a space that feels like it was built for lingering.

Bar counter with cocktail glasses and warm ambient lighting
Assortment of fresh pastries on a wooden display
Customers enjoying drinks at the café counter
Morning light streaming through café windows

What Our Guests Say

The best part of running a café? The people who make it special.

"My go-to spot for morning coffee and the best croissants in the area. The staff remembers your order and it feels like walking into a living room that just happens to serve amazing drinks."

— A Regular

"I didn't know McAlisterville had a place like this. Came in for coffee during the day and came back at night for cocktails — the atmosphere is completely different but equally welcoming. Now it's our Friday tradition."

— A Local Couple

"The Creme Stop is exactly what a small-town café should be — no pretense, just great coffee, friendly faces, and a space where you actually want to stay a while. Their cold brew changed my life."

— A Coffee Enthusiast

Come Say Hello

Address

31016 PA-35
McAlisterville, PA 17049

Hours

Monday – Friday: 6:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Saturday: 7:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Sunday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM

We'd Love to Hear From You

Have a question, want to book an event, or just want to say hi? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you as soon as we can.

Thanks for reaching out! We'll get back to you soon.
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website